Prevention Insights

The Homicidality Modifiers Scale (HMS): What It Tracks and Where It Stands

November 15, 20263 min readBy Homicide Zero Editorial Team

It is easy to picture a risk assessment as a yes or no question. Is a given risk factor present, or is it not. A newer clinical research instrument, the Homicidality Modifiers Scale (HMS), developed by David V. Sheehan, Jennifer M. Giddens, and Ivan Sascha Sheehan through the Harm Research Institute, is built around a different question: how is a known risk factor changing right now. The HMS tracks four domains linked to homicidal risk: impulsive homicidality, hopelessness, loss of enjoyment, and a feeling of being overwhelmed. For each domain, it does not just ask whether the feeling is present. It asks about its severity, a person's ability to resist or experience it, whether their desire to resist it is fading, and how much memories, outside events, and events within their own control are shaping it.

A Narrow Signal Worth Noticing

One item in the HMS structure stands out. Its developers report that the item on a person's loss of desire to hold back a homicidal impulse sometimes gave an early warning of worsening risk before the change showed up in other ways, and they suspect that change may consistently come first. That is a useful reminder for anyone doing prevention work. A warning sign is not always a new statement or a new action. Sometimes it is a quiet shift in how hard someone is still trying to hold a line they have already been holding.

A warning sign is not always something new that gets said or done. Sometimes it is a weakening in how hard someone is still trying to resist a thought they already have.

Where a Structured System Picks Up

Its developers list the HMS as still in field testing. That is a reasonable stage for a clinical research instrument to be at, and it is also why Homicide Zero does not ask frontline staff to interpret a tool like this on their own. Our Homicide Threat Screener (HTS) is a 5 to 10 minute rapid screener built for non-clinicians, people like teachers, HR staff, and security teams who notice a concern and need a fast, structured way to decide what happens next. When a situation needs more depth, it escalates to the Violence Safety and Risk Assessment (VSRA), a 20 to 30 minute evaluation for trained professionals that brings findings together across eight domains into a single four-tier severity rating.

Reassessment Is the Point, Not a Fallback

The idea underneath the HMS, that risk is made of indicators which move rather than a fixed label, matches how structured behavioral threat assessment works more broadly. A case does not end at the first screen or the first assessment. The same situation that produces a Low or Moderate severity rating today can look different in two weeks, and a structured system should make it easy to look again, not treat the first answer as final. Instruments like the HMS are still being tested and refined. The broader lesson they point to, that prevention works best when it treats risk as something to keep tracking rather than something to decide once, does not have to wait for that testing to finish.